Protective Magic

If Looks Could Kill: A Quick History of the Evil Eye

If you follow news on the British royal family, you may have seen photos of a mysterious blue and white pendant worn by Meghan, Duchess of Sussex. This piece of jewelry looks intriguing, but it’s more than just a fashion statement – it has a deeper symbolism that’s thousands of years old. To find out why the Duchess’s pendant is a big deal, we need to take a trip through unexpected mythological territory: the legend of the evil eye.

Ancient Evidence in Egypt, Mesopotamia, and Europe

Ancient Middle Eastern cultures linked the eyes to supernatural power. The most prominent example comes from Egypt – the Eye of Horus. According to ancient Egyptian mythology, Horus was the son of Osiris and Isis. Dictionary.com mentions the legend in which Horus loses an eye battling his uncle Set. Some versions of the tale say that the goddess Hathor restored his eye. Horus then helped resurrect his father, Osiris, by giving him the regenerated eye.

Other ancient cultures associated the eyes with the potential to cause harm. As Elaine Smith explains in a New York Times piece, an envious or hateful look carried evil that could harm living beings and inanimate objects. Even if one’s gaze didn’t reflect obvious envy or hatred, it still held malicious intent. By gazing or glaring, it was possible to curse another person. That’s the evil eye belief in a nutshell.

Journalist Leila Ettachfini mentions that this belief has existed for a few thousand years. Archaeologists discovered 5,000-year-old Sumerian clay tablets containing prayers to keep away evil eye curses. They’ve also found evil eye imagery within 10,000-year-old paintings on the walls of a Spanish cave.

The Dangers of Paying Compliments

The evil eye embodies envy. And while envy and coveting aren’t technically the same thing, they are closely related. Merriam-Webster defines coveting as feeling “inordinate desire for what belongs to another.” The Jewish Torah warns against this in its Tenth Commandment. But other faiths address excessive longing or desire. There’s the Buddhist concept of tanha, which usually translates as “craving” or “thirst.” Tanha is responsible for human suffering, which fuels the death and rebirth cycle.

Envy and coveting produce destructive outcomes if we act on them. But what if you admire something that another person has – say, a gorgeous jacket? If you’re in the Middle East, you’re better off keeping it to yourself. Some believe that even well-intentioned compliments can bring the evil eye curse. Boasting and pride may also bring it on oneself.

Amulets and Other Magical Protection

Ancient Egyptians wore protective amulets bearing the Eye of Horus to ward off sickness, injuries, and death. But they were intended to shield against general misfortunes. Evil eye amulets, charms, and talismans have specific purposes. They’re forms of apotropaic magic, intended to shield their wearers from misfortune. And they exist in many cultures around the world.

Many evil eye amulets come from the Middle East. Jewish blogger Menachem Wecker mentions the hamsa, an ornate metal hand with an eye inside its palm. The hamsa may have Islamic origins, but it made its way into neighboring Jewish cultures. You’ll also see other types of amulets across the region. The most common version is a blue disc with a single eyeball at its center, usually with a blue iris. You may find them hanging from trees, but they also show up as pendants or bracelet charms.

A Human Coping Mechanism?

With a balanced locus of control, we recognize that we cannot dictate others’ actions. Yet their deeds can still harm us. Strangely enough, the evil eye belief can be an adequate coping mechanism. Rather than trying to control others, we can take measures to deal with our own emotions and provide comfort to ourselves. And for millions of people around the world, evil eye amulets accomplish that very purpose.

Beyond Dungeons and Dragons: Amulets, Talismans, and Other Protective Magic

Magic and fantasy fiction go hand in hand. Magic is woven into the fabric of fictional universes such as Thedas in the Dragon Age video games or Faerûn in the Dungeons & Dragons series. People can possess magical powers, but so can inanimate objects. Want to foil a scrying sensor? You should wear an Amulet of Proof. Going up against a big baddie? Equip the Kitty’s Collar amulet and you’ll instantly resurrect after dying. But protective magical objects aren’t limited to fictional battles. For many ancient peoples, they offered real safeguards from serious threats – both corporeal and invisible.  

Common Threats in the Antiquity

Our ancestors faced a world that was full of perils. If you lived during those times, your first challenge was surviving to adulthood. Our World in Data estimates that nearly half of all children born before the 20th century died before reaching adolescence. In antiquity, those figures ranged between 25% and 57%.

So what killed off these children? Deadly diseases were common, but other threats included famine, accidents, and violence. Some societies practiced infanticide, leaving newborns to die if they were disabled, the wrong gender, or one of too many mouths to feed.

With so many ways to die, you’d think that reaching adulthood would offer some reprieve. But that wasn’t always the case. Threats of disease, starvation, accidents, and violence remained. Depending on where and when you lived, you could become a casualty of war. If you were royalty, someone who wanted your throne badly enough could remove you from it – permanently.

Protection Against Evil

Humans in antiquity devised several ways of dealing with their hostile atmospheres. Amulets, charms, and talismans were common alternatives. These objects are examples of apotropaic magic, aimed at shielding their wearers from harm. Apotropaic magic doesn’t just involve physical objects – other means include crossing one’s fingers or knocking on wood.

Amulets in the Ancient World

Amulets existed in many societies, but some of the best-preserved specimens come from ancient Egypt. New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art shows some of these amulets, which were usually worn by living people or placed near a person’s mummified body before interment. Many were fashioned as pendants or rings shaped like gods, goddesses, animals, or symbols. Some bore text inscriptions. One important key to creating an amulet was a magical act that granted its power.

Other ancient cultures used amulets to ward off evil. Roman parents gave their children protective amulets made from precious metals or gemstones. Archaeologists have found metal versions in ancient Palestinian sites, some inscribed with Hebrew letters. Hand of Miriam amulets were designed to protect wearers against the evil eye.

Talismans and Charms

Amulets are classified as talismans, which are handcrafted objects made to protect those who possess them. But “talisman” is a broader term that also applies to clothing, weapons, or even text written on pieces of parchment. Some Stone Age talismans were inscribed with swastikas, which were universal symbols of prosperity and luck until they were co-opted by the Nazi Party during the 1920s.

Talismans of all sorts were also common throughout the Islamic world. For instance, artisans crafted and engraved metal talismanic bowls to heal certain illnesses. Others, such as necklaces or shirts, served as vehicles of divine protection for their wearers.

Enduring Belief in Unseen Forces

The idea of magic may seem absurd in modern times. After all, we have science and reason to guide us, right? Yet belief in the supernatural persists in many cultures all over the world. Evil eye pendants are becoming high fashion, and good luck charm jewelry remains popular. We aren’t living in ancient times, but we face equal uncertainty as COVID-19 and climate change threaten our world. And with such uncertainties, relying on magical objects may not seem so silly after all.